The Shanghai lockdown
At this point, I think everybody has heard about the lockdown in Shanghai, but I will recap it briefly just in case someone doesn’t follow the news: Shanghai, a city with a population of 25 million, has been in lockdown since the beginning of April (in some parts, since the 20th something of March) due to an Omicron outbreak.
It is interesting to remember that, before the lockdown, the local government had declared there would be no lockdown because Shanghai was too important economically speaking or whatever. Someone who said on social media that Shanghai was going to enter lockdown was detained for spreading rumours. There is now a joke in Chinese social media: A guy is walking on the street and a hazmat-clad guard stops him. “What are you doing outside? Don’t you know the whole city is locked down?”. “Locked down? No, I didn’t know. I have been in detention for 3 weeks because I said the city was going to be locked down and I just came out”.
I don’t want to argue if the lockdown is a good idea or not. China had not had a big outbreak since Wuhan and they don’t want to risk having hundreds of thousands of deaths, like other countries had at the beginning of the pandemic. A big majority of Chinese people agree that they need to take a hard stance against outbreaks because their health system would not be able to cope with huge numbers of infections. It would be a good discussion topic to ask why elderly people were not prioritized for vaccination (when I got my shots in Suzhou a year ago, over 60s were discouraged from vaccinating because the Chinese vaccines had not been tested in old people) and why China has until now not imported Western vaccines, which offer better protection.
But in Shanghai, everything has been done in the worst way possible.
They did not want to admit the city was going to be locked down after all, so they said there would be two partial lockdowns: first Pudong (which is the eastern half of Shanghai, a city divided by a river) would be locked for 5 days and then Puxi (the western half) for another 5 days. People prepared supplies for a few days. Then… heheh, the lockdown was extended indefinitely and people found themselves with no food and unable to go outside to buy groceries. Because, in China, lockdown is for real. Don’t even think of going to the supermarket, walking the dog or taking a stroll in the park. People would wake up at 5 or 6 am to try and place an order in online supermarkets. With limited delivery staff, only a handful of people were able to proceed with their order.
Then the local governments in each district started sending emergency relief packs with food and other essentials, but not everybody received them. There were calls from desperate people to the Shanghai hotline or the emergency services because they had no food left. Then some people started receiving dubious packed goods, with rotten food, fake brands imitating well known ones, expiration dates that came from the future and so on. Who knows where the local governments were getting those products from?
Everybody was complaning about the absolute clusterfuck that were Shanghai pandemic logistics. Every day there were new articles on WeChat that were furiously shared by Chinese netizens, only to see them “harmonized” (i.e. censored) a few hours later. The straw that broke the camel’s back was a video titled The Voices of April (here with English subtitles) in which there were several extracts from real phone conversations. People saying that they didn’t have any food left; a mother crying for help because her child had a fever; a 90 year old man who needed to go to the hospital phoning his community representative, who subsequently told him he was desperate and couldn’t do anything to help him as his superiors were not answering him. But also neighbours helping each other, and police and voluntaries trying to do their best. People who watched it were absolutely in tears (I was, too). When this video, which was not saying anything against the government and didn’t include anything that wasn’t true was deleted, one time after another, because many people reuploaded it, everybody was super angry (although only online, of course, no one went outside to light fires) and started looking for ways to bypass the censorship while talking about the video. One of my WeChat contacts shared a (very timely) video in which Hua Chunying, of the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, says: “There are 1.4 billion people in China and each of them has their own brain and their own opinions, and each of them also has the right to express their opinions on the internet”. Just WOW, whoever remembered that video and shared it at that precise moment was a frigging genius, haha. By the way, Hua Chunying was referring to that time when Chinese internet users were bashing the clothes brand H&M because they announced they would not be using cotton from Xinjiang.
There was also the fact that everybody who was positive, including very old and disabled people, was sent to a “quarantine camp” even if they were asymptomatic. It seems also close contacts, which were not positive (yet) were sent there (and ended up being positive, of course). In those camps the conditions were quite bad, to say the least, and it seems there wasn’t even any medical staff checking on people. Oh, and at the beginning some brilliant mind thought it was a good idea to put positive children in quarantine alone, away from their negative parents. And then fences started to be erected blocking buildings’ doors (not a fire risk, at all) or in the streets, in case people had not noticed there are actually in lockdown jail.
The truth is, when I reread all that I have just written, I wonder how Shanghai residents are so patient. I think I would have killed someone by now if I was there (or maybe I would phone a poor volunteer and say the word “fuck” 30 times, like this German man).
And now it seems the story is starting in Beijing… but I am sure they have learned their lesson and the mistakes made in Shanghai will not be repeated. Let’s hope so, because it surely doesn’t look like China is going to change strategy any time soon… at least not until the CCP’s meeting in October or November when Xi Jinping is going to be “reelected” for an unprecedented third term.
That’s an excellent summary. I had no idea it had gotten that bad.
The thing is, if you consider the actual number of infections and deaths, it’s almost a ridiculous outbreak by Western standards haha. But China is not taking any chances.
Oh I have been reading about the Shanghai lockdown and it is HORRIFYING!! My friend in lockdown in Shanghai is worried because she has two cats… she said if she tests positive, she has to go to a quarantine camp and they “clean” the apartment… and from what I read on the internet, they round up pets and get rid of them!!
I am not one to judge (especially since America has SO many deaths from COVID), but I think staying locked down forever and keeping a “zero covid” stance is just not possible. Not vaccinating the elderly is just mind boggling to me. Look at. Hong Kong…
I really hope Shanghai can open up soon. Those poor people there…
It seems they are starting to give boosters to old people now. Bravo, China, you got the memo.
I have no idea what their plans are. They can’t be isolated forever. Even Japan has reopened… But at this point I am fully convinced that the reasons to keep things like this are not medical, but political. Today a friend told me a Chinese-Spanish influencer couple said in a video that the China situation was due to the fact that China respects the elderly a lot. Right, and that is also why Chinese old people have shitty pensions and need their children to support them financially.
Getting my 27th covid test in Suzhou today.
I hope at least it’s the throat one and not the nose one…
Spain’s initial lockdown drove me loopy and I’m thankful I was allowed to cycle to the supermarket as my few days outing. I can’t imagine how those in Shanghai are feeling. I nearly cried in the lift on our first day of age allotted time slots outside. They must have so much patience not to break out in mass.
Más paciencia que el santo Job, I don’t know if you’ve heard that one 🤣
I haven’t! But I can work it out. John the Jesus that was not to be?!
My son, daughter-in-law and 1 year old grandson live in Beijing. Shanghai’s lock-down has been so horrific, I pressed my daughter-in-law to get emergency supplies laid-up, which they hadn’t done. Now they are. As the mother-in-law I have the power to make requests that culturally must be followed. I usually just ask for pictures of the baby. They seem so complacent — like: “it’s not our building complex that’s locked-down.” I am no longer naive at 70. I hope I have prepared them should the worst happen.
I hope they prepared some supplies. I doubt Beijing will allow things to get out of hand, but maybe they will lockdown whole districts just because of a handful of cases.
Thank you. This is a good description of what’s going on. I love the humor.
I think humor is what keep us sane in difficult situations…
If you don’t laugh you’ll cry. Tons of crazy videos coming out of Shanghai. I’m sure you know from calls back home that we’re having plenty of fun in Suzhou with our “static management” – AKA lockdown light. I’ve been doing daily testing for a month and no kindergarten for almost three months. We can leave our apartments but everything except food related businesses are closed, including malls and parks. Better than full lockdown but still not fun. But hey, at least they’ve learned some lessons from Shanghai. I’m guessing we’ll be in some pretty controlled restrictions until Shanghai is clean as we are the physical wall separating SH from the rest of the country.. Beijing is next up on the wheel of fun. Expats are breaking and heading off to greener pastures.
Yes, I know about Suzhou. Schools closed since before CNY holidays is what would break me. 3 months with the kid at home and nowhere to go? Just kill me already, please. My MIL told me the kids in the last year of high school are locked in the schools and haven’t been home for months. They will just stay there studying until they take the exam I guess.
I totally understand foreigners leaving. When will this end? People haven’t seen their families in at least 2 years. Every time we videocall my in laws I want to cry. My son grew up with them and now he barely recognizes them. He doesn’t want to speak Suzhouhua anymore and forgot all his Mandarin. But I will not go to China while flights are 50,000 RMB per person and there’s a 30+ days quarantine. It’s just ridiculous. BTW, my husband has COVID right now, he brought it from some business meetings in London…I phoned the doctor and he said according to Spanish current regulations he doesn’t even need to home quarantine, but he’s been locked in the guest room since Monday anyway. Had a fever for 3 days and a nasty cough. Now he’s just a bit tired but still testing positive.
Oh, and did you know the song “Do you hear the people sing” from Les Miserables is now banned in China? Hahaha, the other day a friend shared a video of several musicians in Shanghai playing it with string instruments (only music, no singing) and now that video has been harmonized hahaha. Everything is just a big joke.
I have to admit, I like to see what’s trending in the US, and when I saw Shanghai, and next Beijing, I clicked. I then read a horrific account of an American living in Shanghai and his rescue dog, and so I knew about the pet situation. To be honest, I just wanted him to get the F out for the sake of that adorable puppy.
30+ ATK tests? I thought our school was bad with twice a week testing. They’ve since stopped and we’ve been on holiday, so I’m going to assume it will be once a week? I saw this hilarious suggestion that they put a Willy Wonky Golden Ticket in each one. I mean, can I at least try to win the lottery every time I stick this F swab up my nose?
You bring up a good point about China’s vaxxes not as effective as the Western ones. Maybe that’s why they’re so stringent? I don’t know, but this whole situation feels like it’s getting ripe for someone or some group to push back against what seems like an OVERREACTION.
Meh, I don’t think anyone will push back against anything. Chinese people really do have an infinite patience (and Shanghai is just one city, and most people still believe covid infection = death). But there is for sure going to be a foreigner’s exodus (when they can, because for now it is very hard and expensive to get to the airport in Shanghai, haha), and some countries are threatening to move all their companies out of China (I think most countries will think twice now before investing in China).
Hmmm. That’s too bad for the Chinese people, but I see what you’re saying. Yeah, as far as investments, etc, it’s already begun. I think the pandemic though started the ball rolling, and now that the rest of the world is wanting to do business again, they’re like, yeahhh.
Interesting article. I’m next to Suzhou, but some of my students are in Shanghai. They were saying that now each day you get four hours to spend outside. When I asked them ‘what do you do at home if you get bored’? They just said, “eat sweets”..haha
Four hours outside? They are lucky then, not all residential compounds are giving so much freedom. My colleague in Shanghai has been at home for almost 6 weeks, he just could go outside one day at the end of March. And now his compound has stopped accepting non-essential deliveries because they need to disinfect everything and it takes them too long…
Marta, check out this report on the effectiveness of the vaccines, especially the charts starting from p. 41:
Click to access Vaccine_surveillance_report_-_week_10.pdf
I don’t know what the answer is for China but I have been undecided on whether to get the jab since they began rolling out the vaccines. I’ve had the luxury to be undecided because Taiwan, like China, has done very well in controlling the spread of Covid. But now with the Omicron variant seemingly uncontrollable Taiwan is in the process of loosening the restrictions with the eventual goal of “co-existence” with the virus. I will have to make a decision on the vaccines soon and my instinct to stay away from them, until they make vaccination mandatory.
I got one jab of Sinopharm, one jab of Sinovac and then a Moderna booster. I read about Taiwan, I hope the transition goes smoothly there.
Funny story… I got Covid around the time I posted my last comment here. I didn’t know at the time but the symptoms emerged a couple of days later. So, I guess the whole internal debate I had about whether I should get vaccinated is now moot. (-:
Oh, I’m sorry to hear that! Hope you are fully recovered now!
Yeah, I’m fine now. I think with the world opening up it’s just a matter of time before everyone comes into contact with Covid and so we should all try to stay healthy and maximise our immune system, with or without vaccination.
I think I now know why most of the “everything is perfect here” YTbers left en masse the moment they could last year, all of a sudden.
Did they? I don’t follow any YouTuber. Last year life was normal in China… except for the fact that you couldn’t get back if you got out. I guess many foreigners just got tired of being apart from their family for so long.
Some have indeed left China to see family and friends after years apart but these people left this year, just in the past couple of months in fact. And some have gone back to China like this YouTuber: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B6oxzIz9kyM
By the way, I heard about the heat wave in Spain… Stay safe!
Thanks for the link! I’m glad China shortened the quarantine time and that she could go back after only a month and a half. Still, I think tickets are too expensive and procedures too complicated…
Hi Marta, I’m Portuguese and I love your blog. When will you post again? Sorry, no pressure 😊.
Hi Sonia, thanks a lot for your nice words. Work has been crazy since April and as I am not in China anymore it’s been hard to feel inspired to write. Lately I do feel like writing again, let’s see if I can find some time!