Book review: The Moon in the Palace
I love historical fiction. Within this genre, my favourite books are those in which the author does an exceptional researching job and after reading them you go to the Wikipedia page of the main character and check that many of the events described in the story really happened. Last month I read one of those books. Well, in fact, two of them, because they are a duology: The Moon in the Palace and The Empress of Bright Moon, by author Weina Dai Randel. They tell the story of Wu Zetian (624-705 AD), the only female Empress in the history of China (Cixi was Empress Dowager and regent), but before she became Empress.
How could a woman become Empress in the 7th century, when China was basically guided by Confucian thought, which preaches that a woman always has to serve a man? The Moon in the Palace tells it from the beginning. Mei (her given name) comes from a well-off family and she is summoned as a concubine in the imperial palace. But there are hundreds of women living in the palace and many of them never get to even see the emperor, much less spend a night with him. And spending a night with him brings power, position and possibly favours. What can a girl do to be noticed? And how can the relationship with the other women be, when they are also working on gaining the emperor’s attention? Ah, the palace intrigues, the eunuchs, the lies, the backstabbing! The only way to survive is choosing your allies carefully and keeping a nice face in front of your enemies.
I really liked this book. The story is fascinating, especially the court intrigues, and everything is described in exquisite detail: the rooms, the hairstyles, the clothes… I think it is amazing that Weina Dai Randel wrote it in English, which is her second language (she didn’t move to the US until her twenties). As I was reading I was imagining the scenes taking place in the Forbidden City in Beijing, although the Forbidden City did not even exist when Mei’s story took place. However, it is the closest example I can think of, as the original palace from the Tang dynasty in Chang’an (present day Xi’an) no longer exists.
If you follow some of the same blogs I follow, you might have noticed that a lot of people is talking about this book. Jocelyn, Nicki, Autumn and Mary have all posted reviews or interviews with the author, so The Moon in the Palace definitely has the AMWF Seal of Approval. (We should actually create that seal!). I thought I would do something a little bit different to avoid sounding repetitive. I thought I would show you some Tang dynasty artworks so you can picture the characters better when you read the book (because you have to read the book!).
The first question is: how did Empress Wu look like? Autumn has already pointed out that she could not be slender and beautiful (based on what we currently consider beautiful) because beauty standards were very different back then. For starters, people who were considered good looking were plump. I searched a little bit and found out that it is kind of complicated to know how she actually looked like. Most of her portraits were painted many years after she died. I could not find any portraits that were painted during her life (please tell me if you know of any), but this drawing must be pretty close of what court women looked like. It was painted by Zhang Xuan, who lived a few decades after Wu Zetian.
Wu Zetian was a great supporter of Buddhism and the Longmen grottoes continued to be carved during her reign. It is said that the face of the biggest Buddha was modelled after her.
In The Moon in the Palace and The Empress of Bright Moon, one of the favourite sports for the high class men is polo. Check out this figurine!
Another figurine of Tang dynasty dancers:
I hope I piqued your curiosity! You can get The Moon in the Palace in Amazon, Barnes & Nobles, BAM!, Target, Half Price Book store, and indie book stores. The second part, The Empress of Bright Moon, will be released on April 5th.
Add one to the book request list from home! (my old man is the bomb). I’m in. Thanks for the review! I think this is one of only a few Imperial Court historical fictions that l would want to read – due to the fact that 50% of bad Chinese TV is some imperial court nonsense that has soured my opinion of the topic. Any truly good historical fiction book will get my YYSA (yangguizi yeti seal of approval) but it’s even better when it’s about something I find interesting to begin with.
Now I think I’ll start rereading Gore Vidal’s Burr (for like the fifth time) until the book arrives from the states. I firmly believe the best present you can give a China expat is a box of books.
Hahaha I don’t watch those Chinese serials! Did you try the one about Empress Wu with Fan Bingbing? The one that was edited to remove excessive cleavage? Is it any good? (My hopes are not high haha).
I never get books sent from home. Sometimes I order something on Book Depository, or in the Chinese Amazon (sometimes they have incredible offers, I got The Search for Modern China and a huge comic book called Building Stories for 180 kuai each, way less than what they cost abroad). But since I got the Kindle it is mostly digital for me!
NICE! Love the artwork and had no idea Empress Wu supported the Buddhist tradition. The giant Buddha was modeled after her face? Fascinating.
Thanks for the new info and pictures. (And the shout out!)
The second book talks a bit about the Buddhism thing! You’ll see :P
Comprendido, hay que leerlo.
La Tang es mi favorita. Ni idea de la moda entonces. Ays, hubiera arrasao en China yo entonces, ja, ja.
Dicen que Yang Guifei, la concubina favorita de un emperador también de Tang, pesaba 150-200 kg, tenía los dientes negros y llevaba campanillas colgando…
You all presented the same book in a different way using a different style – great job.
I love how you described the competition of the women within the palace and how you shared some art and photos!!
Will be checking the website I use to buy books to see if it is available.
Oh, and a AMWF seal is a great idea!
Someone with art skills should design one! xD
Hi, Marta! Wonderful job on the post! Also pleasantly surprised you know of the Longmen Grottoes constructed under Empress Wu’s order. I’ve always wanted to visit that place! I have to say I’m amazed at the creativity you, and Jocelyn, Autumn, Nicki, and Mary, have poured into the blogs of Empress Wu!
Thanks Weina! I hope you have the chance to visit Longmen and all the other Buddhist caves in China, they are amazing!
Pingback: Past and upcoming blogs and interviews | Weina Dai Randel
Thanks Marta; I am going on-line now to buy this book as it sounds great and I love historical Chines fiction…I have been to Henan Province to see the Longmen Grottoes (which were fabulous)…thanks so much for the review.
I hope you like it!
Just bought it thank you.
Great!! Let me know what you thought of it when you finish :)
Ok will do!!
I love the idea of the AMWF seal of approval, we should totally come up with one!
This was a lovely way to do your review — the pics really bring something to the post. I also visited the Longmen Grottoes and remembered reading about that Buddha being modeled after her face. Thanks for the reminder!
Thanks, Jocelyn! :)
Good review, these two books seem very interesting especially as there’ve been very few novels about Wu Zetian. I’m also a fan of historical fiction too.
Check it out if you have the chance!
I loved this review! Pictures of art and sculpture are a perfect way to pique our interest. You mentioned above that Empress Wu weighed 150-200 kilos and had black teeth. Although I’ve also read the same thing, it’s so hard to imagine. OMG!
Oh, that was not Empress Wu, but Yang Guifei, a very famous concubine from the Tang dynasty. But we don’t know how Empress Wu looked like exactly, so maybe she was also like that, haha :P
Whoops! Getting my facts mixed up. Sorry.
Pingback: Guest Post: Fatal attraction within the palace | Crazy Chinese Family
Pingback: Books with a China theme (2016 list) | Marta lives in China